Search This Blog

Wednesday, December 8, 2021

The School Board Wars

Much like SouthLake, here is a two-part series produced by the New York Times (The School Board Wars) that show us that the country's thorniest battles are being fought at school board meetings, between parents, districts, and school administrations.

What happens in the classroom when it becomes a battleground?  

What is most worrisome about this is...what about the kids?  What do THEY need?  How can we successfully teach those 32 English Language Arts standards if we are consumed with fighting about mask mandates?

The English Language Arts Standards: Reading, Writing, Speaking/Listening, and Language

When we start to get into the nitty gritty of teaching English, we have to look at the standards.  There are 32 standards that pretty much cover everything.

We should look at the English Language Arts Content Standards together.    The standards list everything that an English teacher must teach.

Here's how to think about this enormous document:  there are four strands in English, which I've listed in this post's title:  Reading, Writing, Speaking/Listening, and Language.  ("Language" refers to grammar, usage, punctuation -- the rules that we follow when we read, write, and speak.)

The standards are built and organized as "chunks."  First are the foundational skills for the young ones (and something you will want to know and understand when Mikey starts school); "foundational skills" covers Kindergarten through 5th grade.

The next chunk covers grades 6, 7, 8, or middle school.

The final chunk covers 9-12, and they break these down as 9-10, and 11-12; the standards are exactly the same for 9-10, and 11-12.  In my career, I only taught 11th and 12th grade, so I used the same standards for both grade levels.

Anyway what's cool about how these standards are organized is they point to the same skills throughout a child's education, from Kindergarten to Grade 12; the standard will merely increase in specificity and complexity as a child matures.  Any particular standard in kindergarten will be the the same standard in grade 12.

For example, let's just look at one standard, Reading Standard 2.  Here is the language of "the anchor standard"

R2. Determine central ideas or themes of a text and analyze their development; summarize the key supporting details and ideas.

Here's how it looks in 1st grade:

R2: Retell stories, including key details, and demonstrate understanding of their central message or lesson.

Here it is again in 4th grade:

R2: Determine the main idea of a text and explain how it is supported by key details; summarize the text.

Same standard, 8th grade:

R2:  Determine a theme or central idea of a text and analyze its development over the course of the text, including its relationship to the characters, setting, and plot; provide an objective summary of the text.

And finally, 11-12th grade:

R2:  Determine two or more central ideas of a text and analyze their development over the course of the text, including how they interact and build on one another to provide a complex analysis; provide an objective summary of the text.

Let's spend some time together going over the standards and talking about them together.  These 32 standards are the roadmap for teaching English Language Arts, and I believe I could develop a semester long course to go over this document, (and the ELA/ELD Framework*).   

All I mean to say here is that there is plenty, plenty, plenty to look at and talk about here.

*The framework is a document that is over 1000 pages long!  But that framework explains and demonstrates how to take a standard and operationalize it, implement it, make it real, turn it into a lesson, transform a standard into something that happens in a classroom full of unique human beings.

Kids don't learn from people they don't like

It's important to be human and loving with students, while expecting them to do great things.  Rita Pierson charges me up; as summer was winding down and we were heading back to the classroom for the new year, I'd read, listen, and watch videos, all from teachers who inspire me.



The Passion for Teaching: Two by Ken Robinson

Sir Ken Robinson died just last year; he is a charming and inspiring educator, and we are lucky to have these TED talks on video so we can continue to learn from this wonderful man.

Please watch these two TED talks, and as you watch, jot down five things for each video that you want to talk about.


1.  How to escape education's death valley




2.  Do schools kill creativity?







Tuesday, November 9, 2021

You're the greatest!

Alex,

Wow! What a great deal of information to take in!


Is it strange that I found your calendar to be satisfying? I loved the colors and organization. Correct me if I'm wrong but I feel like it's best to be "overprepared", especially when you're just starting out.  


Your feedback was immense but that is what I expected. You leave no questions unanswered, and I greatly appreciate a response with great detail and structure. I'm glad that there are training resources for teachers to continue learning. 


Boy, I would have loved to observe you in your classroom! 


Last Spring, our class read, The Teacher’s Guide to Success by Ellen L. Kronowitz. I believe the book is a great guide for new or aspiring teachers. The book goes over techniques toward positive discipline, engaging methods, and classroom management.

I was flabbergasted by the instructional guide for seating arrangements. The book states, "...seating arrangements should be consistent with your instructional philosophy.” Younger me always wondered why my teachers would sort seats in certain formations. What I've learned is that seating arrangements help reduce distractions. 

 

I would like to be honest, it's quite nerve-racking yet exiting at the same time. 


I long for the day when I have my own classroom and students. I know that I'll reach my goal, eventually. As for now, I just need to be patient and enjoy the process to get there! Today's positive message that I absorbed was to pace myself and work on one thing at a time. There is so much that needs to be learned.


There's this saying that keeps popping up, "Give people their flowers while they can still smell them." Although we've just met, I consider you a gem in my life. You're full of tremendous experience and an open journal for me to take notes. You ease my anxiety on many occasions and I adore the friendship that we're developing. We may not have a classroom setting, but you're the teacher and I'm the student. I love hearing your stories and reflecting on them. I know that I'll reach my dreams, with you by my side. Once again, I would just like to say, THANK YOU, Alex! 




Wednesday, November 3, 2021

How to Plan Curriculum

To answer your question about planning curriculum...that was mysterious to me when I first started too.  I only had a few lessons during the English Methods class that addressed planning, and I was still confused about planning when I started teaching.  But now, I would say I'm an expert.  I used to teach Backward Planning at our district to new teachers in BTSA (Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment).  Mrs. McKinley also used to teach Backward Planning.  She taught me, then I was tagged to take that job over when she moved on.

Teachers start by looking at their year and how many teaching days there are -- public schools have somewhere around 180 teaching days, or forty weeks.  I used to plan in 10-week chunks.  That's what I worked with during my career.  Your situation may be different, but the principle is the same.



So start with some kind of calendar that shows the whole year.  You might work with a year-round schedule, or the traditional 10-month schedule; mark the days that both you and the kids are off...holidays, breaks, things like that.  You will likely have days that are "student-free" days, where you come in to work but the kids have the days off.  These are professional development days; you'll continue to be trained throughout your teaching career.  Teachers are in class a few days every year, sometimes in the summer, sometimes during the school year, sometimes after school, and sometimes -- all three.

Anyway, next mark where the quarters end, and when progress reports and report cards are due. The semester report cards go on the transcripts in high school; quarter grades do not go on the transcripts.  This will be important to your planning early in the year, and we can discuss this later. 

Next, pencil in testing days.  Your district will produce some kind of assessment calendar, which will include the big state test and several district tests.  Standardized tests are a big part of life for all ELA and math teachers, and science teachers. In addition to state testing, your district will want to collect data on how the kids in your district, in your school, in your classroom, are doing, year-by-year.  

And that's how I would talk about testing to kids:  we're collecting data to see how you and your peers are doing.  It doesn't go into the gradebook.  It doesn't impact your grade in any way.  We just want to see how you're doing, so please just do your best and then forget about it.   I would do everything I could to de-escalate any pressure kids would experience during testing.

Unfortunately, our district would require a "practice" standardized test to see how the kids would do if they had to take the state test today; this process took 3-4 days, and once we got the results, teachers would meet by department and by grade level to discuss where the kids were struggling, and then design instruction moving forward to address the weak spots.  This is a rich area for teacher cooperation and collaboration.  If you are an ambitious teacher and have a good working buddy who thinks and works like you do, the conversations between you about how your students are doing will really accelerate your growth as a teacher.  If you don't have a good working buddy, this "practice test" process will mostly feel empty, just a task to complete.  Anyway, put any district tests on the calendar.

Our English Department had two district-wide writing assessments in the school year -- one in October, and another in March or April -- to see what kind of impact our writing instruction was having on our students, and to inform ourselves as writing teachers.  I was a cheerleader for, and a designer of this assessment; I found it valuable, and any day my kids sat down to write an essay was a good day in my book.  I'll talk about this in detail another time.  These writing tests took 3-4 days to complete, and went on the calendar.  

All that testing takes many days, and it decreases instructional time with your kids. No teacher likes all the testing. They are one weird way that the voter can impact a teacher's working life; standardized tests may have some benefit outside of the classroom for curriculum development and so on, but there is little benefit for the student that I've ever discovered, perhaps practice in dealing with future high stakes, high pressure situations:  college exams, grad school applications, work deadlines. Stressful stuff like that.

Back to the calendar:  next, pencil in stuff like Homecoming Week, Choral Tours, or any ASB stuff that will break up the teaching week.  Assemblies.  Red Ribbon Week.  You need to have those on your radar.  You don't want anything really critical happening during those busy weeks.

So once you have holidays, report cards, Back-to-School night, breaks, tests, Open House, and ASB events marked, you see your real teaching days.  You won't have 180 days anymore.  
 
Then you want to think, "How many formal, multi-draft papers should I collect from students this year?" Let's say four -- one per quarter.  This is NOT the only writing you will be doing in class:  kids will also write on-demand essays (done in class in one or two class periods, like the district writing assessments); kids will write reflections and prompts in their writing notebooks; kids will write online on your class blog.  But you will want at least four multi-draft essays in your plan.

Your district or English department will certainly direct you on this, but you will want to teach several writing domains, something like this:  first quarter, narrative; second quarter, argumentative; third quarter, literary analysis; fourth quarter, informational -- or something like that.  Mark those on your calendar.

Look at the books and literature that's available for you to work with.  Ask yourself, if the first paper I assign is going to be narrative, then what book or collection of stories can we read together to support the teaching of narrative?  All of your ELA text books will have lots of narrative stories, and your book room will have school board approved titles like House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros, and you will think, OH!  Let's read this together, and do lots of narrative notebook writing to practice the form.

I'm going to stop here for now because I have to go do other things.  We haven't talked about standards yet, or how this plays out day by day, hour by hour, in the classroom, and things like differentiating your instruction, assessment, feedback, the role of discussion, collaboration with peers in the English department but also in math, science and social science...on and on and on.

It's a fun career.  Very complex, very social, very creative.

Have a good day!

Tuesday, November 2, 2021

They Say/I Say


This book is so helpful!  I need to find my extra copy and mail it to you.  

(Also, my daughter is coming to visit me for Thanksgiving, so I'm going to send some teacher books down with her for you; she'll park them in the Cerritos College Teacher Trac office (or somewhere) with your name on them.  At least I think that is how it will work...stay tuned.)

They Say/I Say is not only helpful for your life as a teacher of writing in middle school and high school, but it's helpful as a writer of papers here and now.  Here's a PDF of the third edition, and here's a handy little template of the main moves that you can print out and stick in your writing notebook.

Featured Post!

The School Board Wars

Much like SouthLake, here is a two-part series produced by the New York Times (The School Board Wars) that show us that the country's t...